You know those download pages that go:
π βWant this free thing? Cool. Just hand over your email first.β
And boomβyou're magically added to a newsletter you never asked for.
Cue the immediate unsubscribe. Or worse... the cold, soulless spam folder.
Yeah. I donβt do that.
β No forced newsletter sign-up.
Not because I donβt want more subscribers.
But because I want the right subscribers.
π§ Hereβs the thinking:
When I offer a freebieβlike a guide, template, or swipe fileβI let people download it without forcing them onto my email list.
At the download step, thereβs a little optional checkbox that says:
β βYes, Iβd like to subscribe to your newsletter.β
Totally up to them. No hidden traps. No sneaky fine print.
Because if someone checks that box?
It means theyβre not just curiousβtheyβre actually interested.
And if they donβt? Thatβs okay too.
π Why Iβm cool with that:
If someone just wants to grab the freebie and dip?
Go for it. No guilt. No awkward follow-ups.
But if someone finds value in what I sharedβand decides to join the list later?
Thatβs a whole different vibe. Thatβs someone whoβs:
β
Curious
β
Engaged
β
Genuinely wants to hear from me
β οΈ But isnβt that bad for list growth?
Short-term? Yeah, maybe.
I donβt get as many subscribers.
But I also donβt get:
High unsubscribe rates
Low open rates
Sad little engagement metrics that haunt your performance dashboard
Instead, I get:
π₯ People who stick around
π₯ People who open, click, and sometimes even hit reply
π₯ People who arenβt just "here for the free stuff"
π Itβs a self-filtering system.
Iβd rather have 500 people who chose to be here than 5,000 who didnβt even realize they were subscribed.
Because when someone wants to be on your list, youβre not fighting for attentionβtheyβre already listening.
And in email marketing?
Attention is the currency. Not just list size.
π Bonus thought:
Down the line, I can always:
Retarget downloaders with new resources
Gently nudge them again if they change their mind about subscribing
So really, it's not a lossβit's a longer play. With better vibes.
Want more email marketing real talk like this? AND you arenβt subscribed yet?
π Join the list (voluntarily π): https://www.koalalab.rocks/Β